Coal miners demand Albanese government force renewables operators to reveal net-zero progress data
The coal industry – accounting for just under one-third of facilities captured by the safeguard mechanism – sent a submission to the government last Friday calling for the renewables sector to report annually on ambitious commitments made under Labor’s plan to reach net-zero emissions by 2050.
Amid a statutory review into the safeguard mechanism, which Climate Change and Energy Minister Chris Bowen turbocharged to help the government meet its 2030 emissions-reduction target, miners have warned about double standards requiring them to divulge sensitive data while renewables operators avoid scrutiny.
Coalmining bosses, who represent the nation’s second biggest export industry and control facilities covering about 25 per cent of all emissions under the safeguard mechanism, have rejected proposals that would lower the regime’s coverage threshold for heavy polluters or apply higher “decline rates for the coal sector”.
In a safeguard mechanism review submission sent to the Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment & Water, Coal Australia chief executive Stuart Bocking urged the government to demand greater transparency from the renewables sector.
Mr Bocking, whose members include Peabody, Yancoal, Idemitsu, Whitehaven and New Hope Group, said government policy must “ensure annual transparent reporting on other aspects of the net-zero plan to ensure that all goals are on track, including the promised employment and salaries, green exports and energy relief from the renewables sector”.
“This would be an important initiative, complementary to the safeguard mechanism reporting and would underpin the credibility of the net-zero plan in its entirety,” Mr Bocking wrote.
The International Energy Agency’s mid-year coal update released this month predicted another record year for global coal demand. Despite coal-fired power generation declines last year in India and China, the IEA said global coal demand rose by 0.3 per cent to 8.84 billion tonnes (Bt), a record, “highlighting how declines in some major markets were offset by growth elsewhere”.
The IEA forecasts that “global coal demand will grow by 1.2 per cent in 2026, bringing total consumption to 8.94Bt and marking another record year”.
With Australia retaining its position as the world’s fourth largest exporter of coal, Mr Bocking warned the government that “additional costs incurred by the sector that are not borne by our international competitors damage Australia’s competitiveness”.
“Already, Australia has lost some ground, with countries such as Russia and Mongolia eating into Australia’s seaborne metallurgical coal market,” he wrote.
Mr Bocking said restricting access to carbon credits would “almost certainly result in higher costs without additional emissions reductions” and threaten the “viability of specific industries”.
The Coal Australia chief focused on contradictions between how facilities captured under the safeguard mechanism must “provide transparent and timely reporting on emissions”, while other aspects of the government’s net-zero plan and goals are “not subject to the same timely or detailed scrutiny”.
“There exists a misalignment in government policy … The safeguard mechanism and this review are core components of the net-zero plan. All components are intertwined,” he said.
“Yet the annual progress reports do not measure progress towards greater employment in the renewables sector, data on transitioning workforces, along with the flagged higher wages with ‘before and after’ salary-package comparisons.”
Mr Bocking said there should be more transparency around highlighting “progress towards promised cheaper energy bills; the renewables sector’s contribution to local economies through council rates, state taxes including payroll tax; and nationally through export earnings including progress towards the net-zero plan projection that “green exports alone could be $68bn higher in 2050 than in the baseline scenario”.
Coal Australia’s submission argued that higher decline rates were “not aimed at net-zero outcomes but rather at net-zero coal production”.
“The purpose of differential rates is not climate-driven but ideologically driven by those wanting to phase out coal production irrespective of global demand, irrespective of abatement technologies, irrespective of international competitiveness, and irrespective of progress towards alternative domestic energy and export opportunities,” it said. “These were never the design principles of the safeguard mechanism.”
Original article from The Australian by Geoff Chambers.